Jerusalem Syndrome: A Deluge of Messianic Delusions

by Tim Swartz
There are some places on the planet that seem almost to radiate a spiritual power. Early man recognized this and built great monuments on these sites. Over the centuries, Jerusalem has emerged as one of these spiritually energetic places, which makes sense, considering that this ancient, Biblical town has been the focal point of devotion by millions of people for thousands of years. What is most fascinating, however, is the way that some people react to this energy.
  For centuries, pilgrims have been drawn to Jerusalem for its rich historical and spiritual tapestry. Most return home with fond memories of their visit but others are inexplicably filled with the burning desire to remain in Jerusalem to publicly chant and sermonize. This strange reaction to visiting a religious site has become so common that it has been given its own name: the Jerusalem Syndrome.

Filled with the Spirit
The syndrome was first described in the 1930s by Jerusalem psychiatrist Dr. Heinz Herman, one of the founders of modern psychiatric research in Israel, who noted in some of his patients an unusual and often temporary mental state of sudden and intense religious delusions after visiting or living in Jerusalem.
  Jerusalem Syndrome usually affects only Christians or Jews, and interestingly, seems to favor Protestants, who account for 97 percent of all cases. Although the syndrome affects each person differently, it generally begins with feelings of nervousness and anxiety, with the pilgrim feeling a gnawing need to visit various holy sites. Often, they will then shave off body hair, cut their nails, and repeatedly bathe in an attempt to become purified. They then suddenly have a desire to go out into the streets to sing hymns and preach the gospel.
  New Mexican resident Amanda Faks said that while visiting Jerusalem in 2001, she suddenly felt filled with the Holy Spirit and left her tour group to start preaching next to the Wailing Wall. “The words just flowed from my mouth and even though I was wide awake and knew what was going on,” she explains, “I had no control over what I was saying.”
  Faks was temporarily hospitalized and after she was sent home, her unusual symptoms vanished just as quickly as they had emerged.

Intoxication of the Holy City
Dr. Yair Bar El, district psychiatrist for the Ministry of Health, says that for people suffering from Jerusalem Syndrome, the clinical picture is always the same. Most have no past mental instabilities and they do not see strange things, nor hear voices. They remember everything they do, and know who they are.
  For those who have been caught up in the intoxication of the Holy City, removal from the environment is usually the fastest cure. Afterwards, most victims of the syndrome cannot explain what happened to them. Rather, they feel embarrassed and usually do not like to talk about the experience.
  However, the district psychiatrist of Jerusalem, Dr. Moshe Kalian, who has diagnosed many cases of Jerusalem Syndrome, disagrees that most sufferers have had no previous mental problems. “In our opinion, Jerusalem is a magnet for certain people who develop their ideas before they come and act out their behavior once they are here,” he explains.
  But Jerusalem is not alone when it comes to places that can spontaneously initiate symptoms of the syndrome in some people. Places such as Lourdes, Fatima, and Medjugorje, where there have been appearances of holy figures such as the Virgin Mary, are well known for sending pilgrims into fits of religious ecstasy. Cities such as Rome and Mecca have also seen cases of Jerusalem Syndrome.
  Despite years of study, no one really knows what causes the syndrome. Perhaps it is jarring for a serious Bible student to arrive in modern-day Israel where, instead of prophets in sandals, he sees businessmen on cell phones and soldiers on every corner. Or maybe in some people there could be a physical reason for their spirituality, something that is activated by these highly charged locales.
  Interestingly, one doctor thinks that he may have discovered a gene that could be the source of spiritual feelings, and possibly a reason why some people are more influenced by religious centers such as Jerusalem than others.

Locating the God Gene
Dr. Dean Hamer, director of the Gene Structure and Regulation Unit at the National Cancer Institute, discovered that people with VMAT2, a vesicular monoamine transporter that regulates the flow of mood-altering chemicals in the brain, were more likely to develop a spiritual belief in God.
  However, both the scientific and religious communities have criticized Hamer's thesis. “God is not something that can be demonstrated logically or rigorously,” says Neil Gillman, a professor of Jewish philosophy at the Jewish Theological Seminary in New York City. Even so, Hamer believes that people are born with the genetic propensity to be spiritual while culture, history, and environment determine whether one is a Christian, Hindu, Jew, Buddhist, or Muslim.
  Additionally, Hamer suggests that all religions have similar rituals that involve prayer and meditation, which can lead to an intuitive sense of God’s presence. “We do not know God; we feel Him,” he explains.
  This could be the reason why some people respond so bizarrely to holy places—instead of one’s spiritual belief being determined by a person’s genetic make-up, perhaps the “God gene” enables one to be more sensitive to spiritual energies. In certain focal areas, this energy may be so strong that the victim acts almost like a radio receiver, and begins broadcasting for all to hear the signal that is coursing through their very being.
  Even so, what causes Jerusalem Syndrome remains an enigma. Are the symptoms the product of an unstable mind and is it a new development or has it been around for thousands of years? If the source of the syndrome involves energies not yet known to current science, might this suggest that historical Biblical figures such as John the Baptist, the apostles, and even Jesus Christ were influenced by this syndrome?
  Whatever the reasons, this fascinating phenomena shows how little is really understood about man’s need for spiritual enlightenment and a direct relationship with the divine.

from issue #10